The Big Picture
     
Home

Biography

The sounds

The bands

The science

Deciding on adoption

PermAdoption pt 1

PermAdoption pt 2

Deciding on adopting again

OrenburgAdoption pt1

OrenburgAdoption pt2

The Big Picture

 

"Who will catch me if I fall?"

-Opening narration, "Nicholas Nickleby"- the 2002 motion picture.  Young Nicholas rises above his destitute situation to cobble a surrogate family from an eccentric band of misfortunates who grew to care for each other.  The story drives home how "family" is really about relationships, not genetics.


These boys love splashing together!

So who should and should not consider Russian adoption? 

Consider Russian adoption if you:

*Can live with uncertainty of the uterine environment of the child you will have forever

*Can live with knowing little or NOTHING about the child's biological father

*Can live with the state probing your life in ways that couples who can conceive naturally will never endure

*Are not in love with your own genes

*Have a lot of assets you can liquidate or borrow against for cash

*Can have considerable patience for bureaucratic decisions on the part of the Russians that are completely and utterly beyond the control of you or the agency you might hire

*Can endure travel to an almost-3rd-world country

Avoid Russian adoption if you: 

*Want to avoid possible fetal alcohol effects in your child with high certainty

*Don't want the state to decide if you can have a child or not

*Do not envision yourself ever healing emotionally from missing out on a child popping out of your own loins.  This is completely understandable.  Lori still feels a slight twinge of being cheated when she sees a pregnant 40+ year old waddling around.

*Don't have huge gobs of cash

In sum, there is no right or wrong answer, and each would-be parent must decide what is right for him and/or her.  That said, I can honestly say that going through the BS has blessed us beyond measure.

  Can you really put a price on a child?

Well, actually you sorta can.  Figure about $35-40k for agency fees, translation fees, visas, document authentication, home study, background checks, immigration visa, and travel.  However, you can claim an adoption tax CREDIT which will lower your actual tax bill by up to $10,900.  This effectively makes the net outlay only $25k or so.

It is so very tempting, especially considering Russia's notorious culture of graft, to write this whole enterprise off as "buy-a-baby.com," as did our traveling companion Jack from Virginia.  Really though, when I look back at it all, all the paperwork and most of the expenses really spoke to the gravity of what really transpired-- the transfer of an innocent, helpless human life. 

The Russian judiciary and Ministry of Education really DOES scrutinize the means and demeanor of those who would take away its children forever.  Anfisa told us in Orenburg that judges live in mortal fear of making a mistake and transferring custody to a parent who ends up hurting the child.  The dizzying amount of paperwork we had to provide was classic C.Y.A. to back them up. 

In the final analysis, it would have been unseemly to have gone over there with a huge wad of cash and just be able to walk into an orphanage and walk out with a child with no questions asked.  At least the court proceedings provided some sense of legitimacy to the whole process.

Considering steps the Russian government might consider to stave off their population decline, I asked Anfisa our translator during our first trip whether she thought international adoption from Russia would be stopped altogher.  She replied with an anecdote.  When she started translating for international adoptions seven years ago, the baby home in Orenburg was at capacity with 120 orphans, and her agency was the only game in town.  Now there are seven agencies operating out of Orenburg, and the cribs remain full.  Given the dire economic cirumstances of this massively messed-up country, there is NO PRACTICAL alternative to letting children go to foreigners, for they continue to be conceived with no local demand for them.  Anfisa thinks that international adoption is a critical safety valve that will remain open.  I hope to God she's right.

(Jim puts on his scientist cap) A rational appraisal of the situation suggests to me that even with the requirements for a home study inspection and interview as well as background checks for previous abuse, tragedies like the Hilt case are still bound to happen.  The distribution of temperament across the thousands of adoptive parents is bound to have some extremely reactionary, anger-prone individuals at the lower end of the patience bell curve.  Many of these individuals will not even be detectable if they have never had any children at the time of the first adoption process!  Nothing short of a crystal ball could detect them.

Also, consider that for every tragedy, there are several THOUSAND happy endings in this process.  Reports of the living conditions, even just the social aspects, in the Russian institutional system, are full of horror stories of frequent abuse at the hands of caregivers and other children.  Think "Lord of the Flies."  For anyone to argue that it is better to have 10,000 additional warehoused children than 9,999 children in stable homes with one death is a warped mental calculus that I cannot fathom.  Also, it implies that every institutionalized child will survive.  This may not be the case....

When Valentin our Moscow guide was in the grocery store with me, helping me get more provisions for our long weekend stay in Moscow (see Adoption p.3), he made a poignant observation at the checkout line.  "Look at her (he gestured toward checkout girl)-- she was raised in orphanage."  I was puzzled.  "How do you know?" I asked.  "Look at her wrists" replied Valentin.  All along the young woman's wrist were numerous scars of slash marks.  Valentin related how the institution system can drive the children to despair in adolescence, especially the girls.

How can any policy-maker in good conscience condemn virtually every orphaned child to that possibility?  We pray that Russian adoption remains a freely-available option to foreign parents.

Some tips to maximize your chance of a successful Russian adoption experience:

1. Find a reputable adoption agency.  Don't just rely on an agency's cherry-picked list of references.  Go to web sites like frua.org (link below) to see forums and make connections with people who have done already to get a fuller picture of an agency. One caution though-- although institutionalized children typically DO have developmental issues, don't let forum horror stories discourage you.  If you read enough posts on sites like FRUA, you may come away convinced that any child you get is going to be a fetal alcohol train wreck with attachment disorder.  I suspect that the population of frequent adoption forum posters are skewed toward the subset of adoptive parents whose kids turned up with persisting issues.  Meanwhile, the rest of us parents are just cruising merrily along with fantastic kids like a typical family and have never looked back...

Make sure an American agency has ROCK-SOLID RUSSIAN CONNECTIONS based on the testimony of couples who have adopted through that agency recently.  If possible, find out what regions (oblasts) from which a prospective agency gets its referrals.  Is it an area where recent adoptive parents report sadistic judges or reasonable judges?  While each individual judge may be different, I get the sense that each oblast has its own general interpretion and implementation of Russian Federation adoption law.  You'd think that there would be one standard set of specific procedures and paperwork requirements across the country, but that is anything but the case. 

In the big picture, all your American agency does is assist you in cobbling together dossier paperwork, then makes a few international phone calls and/or FedEx.  The good ones will at least give you emotional support and travel tips.  Your agency, and the smoothness and success of your overall experience, is really only as good as its Russian operatives and their connections.  After a long and sad ordeal, my dental hygenist was forced to abandon hope of adopting a little boy she had met on her "first" trip (and who she came to consider as her son) because the local judge stopped providing court dates (and thus custody) for would-be parents who used her particular agency.  She was finally forced to go back over there to meet another child in a different region with judges that were less obstinate.  Meanwhile, little "Alexander" is still in the system, is now probably too old to be likely to adopted, and may be destined for a life of crime and substance abuse thanks to some judge that probably thinks to this day that she acted in his "best interest."

2. Spend the extra $1200+ in fees and travel expenses to hire an English-speaking native Russian pediatrician to fly to your city and evaluate your referral IN-PERSON.  Your translator can translate a regurgitation of a child's medical record, which will probably sound scary as hell.  However, what your hired pediatrician can give you (that the orphanage doctor can't or won't) is a big-picture PROGNOSIS in ENGLISH.  That is absolutely crucial.  You will probably need to make a decision about a referral ON THE SPOT in the sense that if there is a medical condition of a referral such that you cannot accept it, you will at least know right away, and they may be able to locate another adoption-eligible child while you are there.  Besides, there is nothing like a doc being able to physically examine a child directly in-person.  All sending video to an American adoption specialist physician can do most likely is either give some additional comfort, or to prompt you to decide NOT to take a referral-- based only on video, photographic, or chart evidence.  Meanwhile, you need to pony up an extra $6k or so to go back over again for another first trip.

3. Get the youngest referral(s) you can to improve the odds of a successful placement.  It has been the experience of many, including Anfisa our translator, that disrupted placements and other behavioral horror stories are disproportionately from cases where a child older than a toddler has been adopted.  Life in an institution is like a jungle, and kids learn fast to jealously and violently hoard what possessions they come to think of as theirs.  My heart goes out to the older kids, and many are adopted successfully, but often, the environmental and nutritional damage is already done.  Fortunately, there ARE special cultural exchange-type programs in development that present for adoption older children that have been selected by caregivers as being exceptionally resiliant and behaviorally normal.

4. Spend time to learn the 33 letters of the Russian alphabet, if not some actual Russian.  Russian is very consistent, and the language is full of "cognates," words that sound the same in English and Russian, but are simply spelled out in Russian characters, like "Taxi," "Photo," and even "Supermarket."  Unlike the French, the Russians have no qualms about keeping a foreign-derived concept or noun in its original sound.  Doing this will reveal a surprising amount of understandable words from the apparent gibberish.

Should I adopt two at once?

Back in 2004, Lori and I agonized over this one.  Would we ever have the money to do it all again if we only got one child?  Turns out we did, with a little help.  We decided on asking the Ministry of Education for only one child at the time because like many modern American couples, we moved far away from any other family members on account of a job (mine), and had no support system outside of maybe some friends from church who could babysit in a pinch.  More importantly, we were concerned over the social and developmental issues of "artificial twinning," obtaining two unrelated children born within 9 months of each other.  Some agencies will not even do this.  For example, it's really hard not to gravitate toward one child over the other when they're the same age if one is mellow and engaging and the other fussy.

With the increased paperwork difficulty and related expense in adopting from Russia at this time, I have changed my tune.  If you want to have two kids, and have some kind of social support structure or at least have a LOT of patience and familiarity with caring for very small children, then ask the Ministry for two kids from the same district (oblast) and be done with it.  Jack and Renee adopted two and they made it work since their boy was an infant and was toted around at the front of Jack's torso with a Baby Bjorn carrier.

If you adopt two kids at once, you are still only paying for ONE home study, set of background checks and fingerprinting (at least in our state), and will have the same travel expenses whether you adopt one or two.  You will probably have the same court hearing in Russia for both kids if you're patient enough to wait longer to have two eligible children become available at the same time in the same Oblast.  If the two children are not a sibling pair, you will probably have to pay double the agency fee and double the BCIS(INS)- related fees for immigration.  By adopting two at the same time, you will still save tens of thousands of dollars, and more importantly, you will save yourself the massive paperwork hassle of having to do it over again.  Finally, placements to foreign parents continue only at the whim of the Russian government, and there is no gaurantee that you could go back again for a second child down the road.  I would still avoid artificial twinning, though, and would suggest people ask the Ministry for a 2-3 year old and an infant, like Jack and Renee did.  If you're willing to accept a boy or two, the referral for two may come faster than you think!

Families for Russian and Ukranian Adoption (FRUA)


The pot at the end of the rainbow

Our wonderful Ural Mountain boys



How sweet it is!

All the hassles and fatigue of this process have faded in the past.  The benefits endure.  Thanks for reading!